, , ,

A century of trans fat history

A couple of years ago, I started writing for the Washington Times Communities Pages. That eventually moved to Communities Digital News. And then I realized I’m homeschooling four kids, one of whom started high school this past year, and what am I crazy? But it was fun while it lasted. While you can find my old articles at Communities Digital News, the Washington Times Communities Pages scrubbed my stuff. So I thought I’d recycle some of it here.

With all the recent stories of multiple “oops” from government minders about cholesterol and fat, I thought I’d repost my article on the history of trans fats. Since this was a news article, it is decidedly lacking in snark and frippery, but I hope you find it informative. One thing I hope you don’t miss is that there was evidence as far back as the ’50s that trans fats were very much not good for us. Yet is was 30 years later that the “Center for Science in the Public Interest” began pushing them on the American people. (That’s Ralph Nader’s group, FYI). It was only a year ago trans fats were finally banned. Trans fats were pushed on us by government policies (subsidies, rationing programs, etc.) and busybodies (Nader & co) and finally banned by the same. Nannies and bureaucrats: trying to solve the problems they’ve created since the dawn of time.

crisco ad

This was originally published November 2013.

More than 100 years after their development and 57 years after they were first linked to health problems, the Food and Drug Administration is moving to ban man-made trans fats. Last week the FDA announced it was opening a 60 day comment period on proposed regulations that would relabel partially hydrogenated oils as not “generally recognized as safe,” leading to their eventual removal from the food supply.

For most of their history, trans fats had been considered a good alternative to dietary fat from both animals and other sources such as tropical oils. According to the American Heart Association, the hydrogenation process was developed in the 1890s by the French chemist Paul Sabatier. German Chemist Wilhelm Normann then discovered how to make liquid oils into solids, thus developing trans fats. In 1911, Americans first experienced the first man-made fat with the introduction of Crisco shortening.

As more food production was moved from homes and small businesses to factories and with rationing and shortages during World War II, margarine and shortening began to replace butter and lard. The big switch to trans fats, however, came in the 1980s with a public advocacy campaign by the Center for Science in the Public Interest.

In a 2012 article in Technology and Culture, the journal of the Society for the History of Technology, David Schleifer writes, “In the 1980s, responding to the connection that medical authorities made between saturated fats and heart disease, CPSI and another activist organization, the National Heart Savers Association (NHSA), campaigned vigorously against corporations’ use of saturated fats, endorsing trans fats as a healthy, or healthier, alternative.”

Schleifer notes that not only did the scientific opinion of the time support this view, but that, “growers, oil suppliers, and academic and government scientists had been working since the early twentieth century to commercialize soybeans and develop the partial-hydrogenation process.” For soybeans in particular, partial-hydrogenation was necessary to make them acceptable for the food supply as the process removed unpleasant tastes and odors.
A higher-grade tumor is dispersed with uneven edges that are apt to spread cialis buy cheap mouthsofthesouth.com rapidly. Male impotence, also known as erectile dysfunction, refers to the inability of a person to have erection of his penis, and maintaining prescription viagra prices that erection for longer period of time. It is by way of intimate intercourse that human race is still present up to this time. mouthsofthesouth.com buy cheap levitra Illegal or commander levitra unethical pharmacies sometimes send outdated, substituted, or counterfeit medications.
The public campaign not only targeted animals fats, such as the tallow McDonald’s used to fry their potatoes, but also tropical oils like coconut and palm oils. An ad campaign from NHSA called “Who’s Poisoning America,” said, “We implore you. Do not buy products containing coconut oil or palm oil. YOUR LIFE MAY BE AT STAKE.”

Schleifer writes that from 1981 to 1993, CPSI pushed food producers to transfer from saturated fats like lard, tallow, butter, palm, and coconut oils to trans fats. The push was effective and much of the food industry responded by switching to PHOs. However, in 1994, scientific opinion changed again.

At that time, scientific research was beginning to prove what the 1956 study had suggested, that trans fats were more harmful than other fats and contributed to heart disease. Making an 180-degree change in their policy, CPSI began to petition the FDA to require trans fats be labeled on foods. In 2006, this policy was implemented by the FDA.

In 2007 Crisco, the first product with PHOs to be marketed in the United States, removed trans fats from their products. Other companies have made similar moves, and the presence of trans fats has been greatly reduced in the food supply.

In response to last week’s move by the FDA to ban trans fats, CPSI said in a press release, “In 2004 CSPI called on the agency to revoke partially hydrogenated oil’s status as a safe food ingredient altogether.” The organization who first advocated large scale adoption of trans fats has come full circle.

Some experts suggest the initial war on saturated fats was misguided in the first place. Writing in Science Magazine, Gary Taubes notes that despite the reduction of fat in American diets, the incidence of heart disease does not seem to be declining, although deaths from heart disease have dropped, most likely from medical advances. Meanwhile other health problems such as obesity and diabetes have grown.

Taubes notes that while much research has been done on various aspects of fat, cholesterol and heart disease, no causal links had been made between the steps that have been assumed to make a whole. He writes, “Despite decades of research, it is still a debatable proposition whether the consumption of saturated fats above recommended levels (step one in the chain) by anyone who’s not already at high risk of heart disease will increase the likelihood of untimely death (outcome three.)”

Whether the ban on trans fats brings us back to saturated fats or some other innovation is yet to be seen. As nutrition science develops and advocacy groups endorse various theories, these battles will probably continue to play out in the public and political arena.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Clean Notebook is a captivating Full Site Editing (FSE) theme that beautifully captures the essence of simplicity and minimalism.

Main Pages
Useful Links

Copyright © Clean Notebook, 2023. All rights reserved.